Business Blockbuster - Helpng business to be more visible on Google

Daily Bulletin

‘Exceptional circumstances’: why was Ben Roberts-Smith granted bail?

  • Written by: Melanie O'Brien, Professor of International Law, The University of Western Australia

In early April, one of Australia’s most decorated soldiers, Ben Roberts-Smith, was arrested and charged with five war crimes of murder.

These charges were brought under the Commonwealth Criminal Code Act.

On Friday, a bail hearing was held in Sydney. Roberts-Smith appeared remotely from custody and his lawyers requested bail in person.

The judge granted Roberts-Smith bail based on “exceptional circumstances”.

The allegations and the arrest

The allegations against Roberts-Smith relate to five separate killings of people in various locations in Uruzgan Province, Afghanistan in 2009 and 2012, where he served with the Australian Special Forces (the Special Air Service regiment, also known as “the SAS”).

Read more: Ben Roberts-Smith is accused of 5 war crime murder charges. How did we get here?

These allegations were already known in the media and through the failed defamation case that Roberts-Smith brought against Nine Entertainment.

The wider context of the alleged offending came to light in 2020 following the release of the Brereton Report which found credible information that members of the SAS had committed war crimes during operations in Afghanistan between 2005 and 2016.

On April 7, Roberts-Smith was arrested at Sydney Airport by Australian Federal Police officers and taken into protective custody in Silverwater Prison.

What makes bail so important?

A day after his arrest, a remote bail hearing took place. Roberts-Smith’s lawyer did not request bail. It is unclear why. Bail was then requested at a hearing on April 17.

Bail is an important aspect of fair trial. Courts must consider the rights of the accused, such as the right not to be punished prior to being found guilty.

But courts must also mitigate any potential risks from the accused’s behaviour, which may include harm to the community or interfering with the course of justice. Also considered is whether a person is likely to appear at their subsequent court hearings or if there a risk of absconding or fleeing.

It is notable, however, the general trend in Australia is towards decreasing access to bail, as courts are increasingly risk averse.

This is particularly so with serious offences.

Are there any precedents in Australia?

It is difficult to compare the idea of bail for war crimes with bail decisions for “ordinary” crimes – even murder. This is because one of the considerations for bail is whether someone is likely to reoffend if they are out on bail.

In the case of war criminals, they are obviously no longer in a warzone – they are likely not going to reoffend while on bail.

Australia has almost no war crimes prosecutions in its history, with no conviction for the only previous prosecution which related to the second world war.

But we can look to the one other case of war crimes charges currently before the courts – Oliver Schulz, another SAS soldier.

In March 2023, Schulz was arrested and charged with the war crime of murder. This relates to an alleged killing carried out while Schulz was serving in Afghanistan.

Under the Commonwealth Crimes Act, bail is not permitted to be granted for a person accused under Commonwealth law of causing the death of a person. Only in “exceptional circumstances” will bail be justified.

After being arrested, Schulz was initially refused bail. However, eight days later, he was granted bail.

His lawyer argued there were “exceptional circumstances”, namely Schulz would be vulnerable in jail. He would likely encounter Islamic extremists, which would be a security risk for Schulz. The magistrate agreed and granted bail.

Schulz’s bail came with a long list of conditions:

  • a bail security of A$200,000

  • surrender of his passport

  • prohibition on contacting any of his fellow SAS soldiers

  • barred from contacting any prosecution witnesses

  • a curfew

  • reporting to police daily (this was later amended due to practicalities of the station’s opening hours).

What about Roberts-Smith?

Roberts-Smith’s situation is different from Schulz.

Firstly, he is charged with five war crime murders, not one. Studies have shown chances of bail decrease when there are more charges and when the offences are serious.

Secondly, Roberts-Smith has sufficient financial means to abscond, as well as wealthy financial backers. This would support his ability to pay a bail security, which increases the likelihood of bail being granted. However, it would also provide the means for international travel.

Thirdly, Roberts-Smith is known for travelling internationally, including during court proceedings.

This indicates he may be a high flight risk.

Fourthly, the court must consider the risk of Roberts-Smith interfering with the course of justice.

A judge previously found Roberts-Smith threatened witnesses in his defamation case.

What did lawyers argue at the bail hearing?

These factors were raised by lawyers for both sides in Friday’s bail hearing.

Roberts-Smith’s lawyers argued he also met the threshold of “exceptional circumstances” in that staying in prison would not be safe. They argued he was not a flight risk, had been cooperating with authorities, and had not attempted to contact witnesses involved in the case.

Barrister Slade Howell argued for bail because the case would likely take years due to the complexity of the case and that Roberts-Smith would not be able to prepare his defence if he was in custody.

Prosecutor Simon Buchen argued against bail because of the serious gravity and scope of the charges. He also charged Roberts-Smith was a flight risk, alleging the accused had planned to move overseas and he had withheld this information from authorities.

Buchen presented the most significant risk as the potential for interference with witnesses or evidence and subversion of the court process.

Buchen acknowledged strict bail conditions could mitigate the flight risk but not the risk of interference in the course of justice.

Judge Greg Grogin found the risks presented by the prosecution would be mitigated by bail conditions, with those being:

  • report to a police station three times a week
  • only use a single phone and computer, which must be made available to police if requested
  • a $250,000 bail surety
  • permission to travel to Sydney and Perth for legal or medical reasons
  • prohibited from interfering with witnesses or evidence
  • surrender of passport

The decision diverges from typical bail trends in Australia which emphasise the seriousness of the crime, flight risk and the risk of interference with justice.

Schulz will face trial in February 2027. Roberts-Smith’s trial date remains to be set – we will know more at a status hearing set for June 4, 2026.

Authors: Melanie O'Brien, Professor of International Law, The University of Western Australia

Read more https://theconversation.com/exceptional-circumstances-why-was-ben-roberts-smith-granted-bail-280453

Business News

The Growing Demand for Durable Plastic Packaging Supplies Across Australia

Why Do Australian Businesses Need Reliable Plastic Packaging Supplies? Businesses need packaging that can withstand everyday handling, storage, and distribution without creating avoidable delays. Pla...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Choosing the Right Scope for Your Office

A well-planned office cleaning Melbourne arrangement starts with a clear understanding of the premises and the people who use it. An office may include private work areas, shared desks, reception, mee...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Businesses Can Prepare for Unexpected Power Outages

Power failures can occur quickly. The supply may be interrupted by bad weather, issues with the electricity network, damaged equipment or local construction work. This can be just a hassle for a fam...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Chatswood Tutoring Can Fit Into a Student’s Weekly Routine

Create a Predictable Weekly Structure A consistent weekly routine can make study easier to manage when students are balancing several subjects. Chatswood tutoring can provide a fixed learning point a...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

The Rise of Digital Marketplaces in the Australian Trade Sector

For decades, the Australian trade and construction sector operated almost entirely on word-of-mouth recommendations and local community networks. Small business owners typically relied on local newspa...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Immigration Lawyers Can Help

Introduction Visa decisions can shape employment, family life, study plans, travel, and future residence. A small omission can lead to delay, added expense, or refusal. Immigration lawyers assess l...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Industrial Drying Equipment Supports Efficient Processing

Many industrial processes require moisture to be removed from compressed air, products or process materials before they move to the next stage. Excess moisture can affect equipment performance, produc...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Practical Ways a Whiteboard Can Improve Workplace Communication

Effective communication helps teams stay organised, share ideas and keep track of important information. While digital tools are now common in many workplaces, a whiteboard continues to provide a simp...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Designing Eco-Friendly Custom Water Bottles for Your Next Event

The Evolution of Sustainable Event Merchandise Event planning has undergone a massive transformation over the last decade. Gone are the days when organizers could hand out cheap, single use plastic...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

The Daily Magazine

What to Consider Before Installing a Built-In Wardrobe

Living in a modest home teaches you a lot. You learn how to keep a small kitchen tidy, where to hi...

Top 5 Mortgage Brokers in Sydney: How to Choose the Right One in 2027

Finding a mortgage broker in Sydney is not particularly difficult. Finding one who understands your ...

How Much Life Does Your Roof Have Left? Recognizing When Replacement Becomes Necessary

A roof can age quietly for years. From the street, everything may look reassuringly ordinary, even w...

How Australian Drivers Can Make Their Cars Harder to Steal

Most people don't think much about car theft until it happens to them, or to someone they know. Th...

The Short-Term Rental Rules Australian Owners Can’t Afford to Guess At

A holiday let looks simple from the outside: a spare property, a listing, some guests. Underneath ...

The Risks Of Removing Ear Wax Without Professional Guidance

Ear wax is an essential component of the hygiene process since it acts as a barrier between the ea...

Plumbing Call-Out Fees in Perth Explained

When you hire a plumber to fix a problem with a dripping tap, leaking pipe, or whatever it might be...

Workshop Tool Maintenance: A Practical Guide to Drills, Sanders and Table Saws

A drill that strips every screw head. A sander that leaves swirl marks however long you work the pan...

How Architecture and Engineering Firms Can Improve Project Profitability

Project profitability remains one of the most persistent challenges for architecture and engineering...