Daily Bulletin


The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation
imageHolding kids back a grade does more harm than good.AAP/Dan Peled

If you take a typical Australian classroom and line up the students by their current achievement levels, you will find a five- to six-year spread between the most and least advanced 10% of students. When students are being left behind the solution presented is often to hold them back a grade, making them repeat a year level.

Every year thousands of students repeat a grade for academic or social reasons. The OECD estimates about one in 12 Australian students are held back at some point in their schooling.

The idea is that if struggling students are given extra time to mature or to master educational building blocks that they’ve stumbled on, they’ll fare much better in the years ahead.

While the logic is seductive, the evidence is unequivocal: holding kids back is the wrong solution. Not only is repeating a year unhelpful, it’s one of the few educational interventions that does a great deal of harm.

According to the evidence, if you take two students with similar levels of achievement and hold one back, after a year the retained student will be on average four months behind the other in terms of academic achievement.

The retained student will also have lower self-esteem, attend school and complete homework less often, be less motivated and have a more pessimistic view of their academic potential. Despite completing an additional year of schooling, they are unlikely to ever catch up with their peer and are more likely to drop out of school without finishing.

imageBeing held back is not only bad for the student academically, but also for their self-confidence.from www.shutterstock.com

There will always be exceptional circumstances where grade repetition may make sense for an individual student. But, on average, repetition is incredibly harmful. The evidence shows it’s very difficult to predict ahead of time whether a given student will prove the exception or the rule.

No parent would ever knowingly sign their child up to the bleak outcomes described above. But the decision to retain is often born of desperation. If their child has moved up a grade year after year, only to fall further and further behind, how can more of the same help?

Unfortunately, it’s likely that grade repetition also promises more of the same. If a Year 9 student is struggling to meet grade-level expectations, chances are they have missed out on core learning skills earlier on.

Sitting through the same curriculum twice won’t help much. Instead, the child needs strategies that provide additional support targeted at the precise areas in which they are having difficulty.

A different solution

There are better ways to address the needs of struggling students in Australian classrooms. We need to abandon faith in permanently segregating students according to ability through grade repetition and streaming.

The evidence is clear that these don’t lift overall achievement. Grade repetition harms the students who need help the most, while streaming benefits a minority of high-achieving students at the expense of the rest and has a negative impact overall.

Even in streamed classes, learning needs for individual students will differ. One child may be writing at a level roughly two years ahead of most others in his Year 8 English class, while still needing extra help with grammar. Ignoring these differences can mean that basic gaps balloon into broader obstacles to future progress, while opportunities to excel are left untapped.

Instead of trying to eliminate classroom differences, we should provide teachers with the support they need to differentiate the curriculum, rather than pitching it at the classroom average or at year-level expectations.

In this approach, which we describe in our recent Grattan Institute report Targeted Teaching, teachers collect evidence of their students’ learning needs on a continuous basis and integrate it into their teaching. They use it to pinpoint what their students are ready to learn, and target their teaching accordingly. They also use it to identify what and how much their students have understood, so that they can give effective feedback to their students and evaluate the effectiveness of their own approach as teachers.

Targeted teaching can ensure that learning difficulties are quickly identified and addressed, rather than left to fester year after year. It could dramatically reduce the temptation to have children repeat grades.

Targeted teaching requires making a better range of assessment tools available in every school, and providing teachers with time and training to use the tools and interpret the results. Schools can start by using resources more effectively, but many will require significant additional support from education systems.

Ultimately, the investment will be worth it. It costs at least A$8000 to have a student repeat a grade, much more in some schools. At this rate, we’re wasting about A$200 million on every new cohort of Prep (or Kindergarten) students as they move through school. (This was calculated by multiplying A$8000 by 8.4% – one in 12 – of the 310,198 students in Year 1 of schooling in 2014.)

And this accounts only for the direct costs of an additional year of schooling. When repetition backfires, the economic and social losses can be many times larger, for both the student and the country.

The evidence is overwhelmingly clear that repetition should not be the default system response for students who fall behind. What’s needed instead is a proactive educational approach that monitors, identifies and responds to learning needs before they become learning problems.

The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond the academic appointment above.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/grade-repetition-there-are-better-ways-to-move-kids-forward-than-by-holding-them-back-47269

Writers Wanted

Vital Signs: yes, we need to make things in Australia, but not like in the past

arrow_forward

How a university can embed Indigenous knowledge into the curriculum and why it matters

arrow_forward

Do criminals freely decide to commit offences? How the courts decide

arrow_forward

The Conversation
INTERWEBS DIGITAL AGENCY

Politics

Prime Minister Interview with Kieran Gilbert, Sky News

KIERAN GILBERT: Kieran Gilbert here with you and the Prime Minister joins me. Prime Minister, thanks so much for your time.  PRIME MINISTER: G'day Kieran.  GILBERT: An assumption a vaccine is ...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Did BLM Really Change the US Police Work?

The Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement has proven that the power of the state rests in the hands of the people it governs. Following the death of 46-year-old black American George Floyd in a case of ...

a Guest Writer - avatar a Guest Writer

Scott Morrison: the right man at the right time

Australia is not at war with another nation or ideology in August 2020 but the nation is in conflict. There are serious threats from China and there are many challenges flowing from the pandemic tha...

Greg Rogers - avatar Greg Rogers

Business News

Expert Tips on How to Create a Digital Product to Sell on Your Blog

As the managing director of a growing talent agency, I use the company blog to not only promote my business but as a way to establish ourselves as an authority in our industry. You see, blogs a...

Adam Jacobs - avatar Adam Jacobs

How to Find A company with Tijuana manufacturing

If you have decided to launch a business in Tijuana, there is a need to know about the manufacturing companies. The decision to choose a manufacturing company is not so easy as it looks.   The rig...

News Company - avatar News Company

Tradies are actually getting on well. ServiceSeeking's data surprises

Across the Top 20 Industry Categories for Household Trades and Home Improvement  3 Industries are showing massive growth in jobs listed: Rubbish Removal, Carpet Cleaning, and Door Installation 4...

Jeremy Levitt - avatar Jeremy Levitt



News Co Media Group

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion