Daily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation
imageNow you see it, soon you won't.EPA/Alessandro Di Meo

On the shores of the Mediterranean, we are about to witness a great magic trick. Over the next few weeks the bodies of migrants trying to make it to Europe will disappear.

The British government has already tried once to make the boats themselves disappear. In October 2014, it withdrew support for...

imageNow you see it, soon you won't.EPA/Alessandro Di Meo

On the shores of the Mediterranean, we are about to witness a great magic trick. Over the next few weeks the bodies of migrants trying to make it to Europe will disappear.

The British government has already tried once to make the boats themselves disappear. In October 2014, it withdrew support for extended search-and-rescue patrols. The stated reason was that the patrols would encourage more people to take to boats because they knew they would be rescued; the unstated hope was that any future boats would simply come ashore – or sink – without public notice.

But that trick didn’t work for a number of reasons. The public already knew the people were there and a backlash was quickly building against the decision to stop rescuing them. What’s more, there was both a ready supply of desperate people willing to get into the boats and there was an established business model of smuggling (and sometimes trafficking) these people across the Mediterranean.

But this time the trick will succeed. This time European governments will target and destroy the boats. The aim is, in the military vernacular to pursue the “neutralisation of smugglers vessels and assets”. We are led to believe that there will be no more boats on which to embark. But the real magic will occur where we are not looking. Like any great magic trick, the disappearance of the boats relies upon the theatre of misdirection.

In the coming months, “partnership” agreements with governments in Egypt, Libya and Tunisia will provide incentives for those states to intercept, detain and deport migrants and refugees before they even get onto the boats.

The EU has begun to negotiate with Eritrea to impose tougher border controls in a bid to catch those who would otherwise flee the persecution of that very same state. Meanwhile, the EU also plans to disperse those who do manage to arrive (though not to the UK). If the EU doesn’t take this action, Italy’s Plan B is to do this itself by releasing and regularising new arrivals for travel through a borderless Europe.

imageMen await help after arriving at the Franco-Italian border.EPA/Sebastien Nogier

While we are paying attention to the few boats that are seized or set ablaze, the supply of migrants and refugees will be diminished and the remainder of the boats will simply not set sail. And those who do embark will embark on longer and more diverse journeys to Europe. They will travel to discrete coves or by land and plane to a range of destinations throughout Europe. Those that do arrive will be quickly dispersed, away from the beaches of holidaymakers and the eyes of the media.

In short, the unstated hopes of October 2014 will be realised and credit will be given to the determined political leaders and brave soldiers guarding Europe’s southern frontier.

Tried and tested

I know this will happen because the model is tried and true. It is what Australia has accomplished and what is currently being negotiated in South-East Asia to deal with the influx of Rohingya.

In both places, militaries are taking over in an attempt to solve the problem. In the case of the Rohingya, the Thai navy used to simply tow the boats back out to sea, only for them to come ashore elsewhere more secretly. Now the Burmese military stops the boats from leaving. The Bangladesh government has also coincidentally announced plans to relocate the refugee camps housing the Rohingya to a more remote location.

Meanwhile, Australian operations to tackle the boats are shrouded in the kind of secrecy usually confined to military operations. There are reliable accounts of smugglers being paid to turn their boats around. And Australia is spending millions of dollars trying to strengthen the ability of transit states to intercept the boats.

Looking the other way

But the real magic trick isn’t about making the boats disappear. The real magic is in distracting us from what causes them to appear in the first place – horrific conditions in countries of origin and the lack of any protection in countries of transit.

In the Mediterranean, the vast majority of those taking to the sea are trying to escape Syria and Eritrea. The former is a humanitarian catastrophe and one of the most dangerous places on Earth; the latter is forcing its people into endless military service. The states that host Syrian and Eritrean refugees in transit continue to receive inadequate support from the international community and to offer inadequate protections.

Making the boats go away is a magic trick; it is an illusion. The root causes of the migratory flows to European shores will remain and won’t be solved either by bombing boats or outsourcing border controls to neighbouring states. And the people, the vulnerable migrants and refugees, will remain, simply out of sight.

Even more troubling, like all magic, there is a profound complicity between the audience and magician: we don’t want to confront the hopelessness that drives people to embark in risky voyages across the Mediterranean. Until we confront this truth – and resolve to address it – our politicians will continue to wave their wands and shout abracadabra.

Martin Jones does not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has no relevant affiliations.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/do-you-believe-in-magic-how-european-sleight-of-hand-will-make-migrant-boats-disappear-43301

An ever innovative director, Peter Brook reminded us how high the stakes of theatre can be


The Conversation

Business News

How to Provide the Best Service Your Industrial Business Can

In the current business world, you may very well find that the difference between your business and that of your closest competitor is that of customer service. This is good as it is an area where...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

WhiteBIT continues its transcontinental expansion and enters the Australian market

Europe's largest crypto-exchange WhiteBIT continues to grow its business globally. The company has now joined the massive adoption of blockchain technology in Australia. By providing a secure and ea...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Business Permit Processing Works in the Philippines

Are you an aspiring new business owner? A business permit is a must for any establishment here in the Philippines. Without it, you have no legal right to run one. But do you know how the permit pr...

Angelo Castelda - avatar Angelo Castelda

WebBusters - Break into local search