We can turn CO<sub>2</sub> in the air into new materials – but don't expect that to stop climate change

What if there were a way to suck carbon dioxide right out of the air and turn it into useful products? It might seem fantastic but scientists have actually proved it’s possible. One of the challenges with making it a viable process, however, is manufacturing products that are valuable enough to cover the high costs of extracting the carbon dioxide.

Some excellent new research has raised the possibility of a breakthrough in this area by using CO₂ directly captured from the air to produce a type of graphene, the two-dimensional form of carbon often described as a “wonder material”. But reported claims that this amounts to producing “diamonds from the sky” are somewhat misleading.

There is already a significant market for CO₂ and products made from it, most obviously fertiliser and fuels. This process of treating the gas as a feedstock rather than a waste product is known as carbon dioxide utilisation (CDU) and usually starts by capturing CO₂ from industrial flue gases – exhaust from furnaces or fuel-powered generators.

Drop in the ocean

In 2012, carbon dioxide utilisation accounted for 180 megatonnes of CO₂ that would otherwise have gone into the atmosphere, and this has been forecast to rise to 256 megatonnes in 2016. But total global greenhouse gas emissions are around 35 gigatonnes and rising, meaning other emission-reduction strategies such as energy efficiency and renewable power currently play a much larger role.

Sucking CO₂ directly from the air can be a trickier process compared to more concentrated sources such as flue gases. As CO₂ represents just 0.04% of the atmosphere, you have to treat very large amounts of air just to produce even modest quantities of the gas. However, several companies have managed to design chemical processes that are more efficient than those used in flue gas capture and produce enough industrial CO₂ to be economically viable.

Carbon nanofibres: cylindrical layers of grapheneWikimedia Commons/Magnus Manske, CC BY-SA

The new research from George Washington University in the US demonstrates a way to directly capture CO₂ from the air and turn it into carbon nanofibres, powered just by a few volts of solar electricity and solar heat. These smaller-than-microscopic structures are effectively irregular cylinders made from layers of graphene and can be used to strengthen materials for building aircraft, wind turbines and even sports equipment.

The researchers claim their new manufacturing method is much cheaper than existing techniques and so could open up new uses for the nanofibres. If they can scale the process up to the level of mass production and keep it cost-effective, this would really help grow the market. But a robust life-cycle analysis is needed to substantiate these claims.

If the technique does prove to be a cheap way of mass-producing carbon nanofibres, could it become so widely used that it significantly reduces atmospheric CO₂ levels, a claim attributed to the authors (but not in the peer-reviewed paper)? Current production of carbon nanofibres is around 500 tonnes a year and predicted to increase to around 10,000 tonnes a year. But this is still far from the hundreds of millions of tonnes that would be needed to make a meaningful contribution to greenhouse gas levels.

Starting point

It is difficult to see at this time how a market for carbon nanofibres could develop to these levels. One exception might be if the price of nanofibres became so low we could start using it to cost-effectively strengthen building materials. This would also provide an interesting addition to current techniques that turn CO₂ and other chemicals and waste products into stable solids.

Developing viable direct air capture techniques is a major research challenge that will hopefully one day have far-reaching impact. It could help make CO₂ a resource that is available anywhere in the world where a capture unit can be installed. Carbon nanofibres will play a part in the portfolio of technologies that make up carbon dioxide utilisation, again an area that is growing in application and promise.

Sadly it’s most unlikely this interesting breakthrough will be scaled up to limit climate change in the way that has been claimed. We believe that due to the size of the potential market, carbon nanofibres alone will not be able to make a significant impact on CO₂ mitigation. However, many transformative technologies and materials start with a niche area before moving into more mainstream uses. And perhaps this could be the case for direct air capture nanofibres. After all, change has to start somewhere.

Peter Styring receives funding from EPSRC, BBSRC, European Commission

Grant Wilson is a researcher with the European Smart CO2 Transformation project. www.scotproject.org

Katy Armstrong receives funding from EPSRC and European Commission.

George Dowson receives funding from EPSRC