Business Blockbuster - Helpng business to be more visible on Google

Daily Bulletin

Five years after the end of provocation, jealous male killers still receive leniency

  • Written by: The Conversation
imageIs justice being done?Ronnie Macdonald, CC BY

In the UK, men can no longer claim they were provoked by jealousy into killing their partner.

Our research published recently in the Cambridge Law Journal revealed the extent to which that change, enacted in 2010, has altered the way the English courts have responded to murder motivated by sexual infidelity. The answer is not as much as we might have hoped.

As a defence to murder, provocation had long caused controversy in the English courts. On one hand, the defence largely failed to accommodate the desperate experiences of women who have killed a long-term abusive male partner. On the other, the defence too readily accommodated the contexts within which jealous and controlling men killed women who were leaving them or had committed infidelity.

The replacement of the provocation defence with a new partial defence of loss of control signalled an effort to ensure the law was able to better address the gendered contexts that surround a large number of homicides.

Loss of control

The new partial defence of loss of control retains some features of the old provocation defence, while also bringing in new provisions. One provision limits the defence reducing murder to manslaughter in cases where someone loses control when they find evidence of what the law now calls “sexual infidelity”. At the time the reforms were introduced, the Ministry of Justice stated:

The government does not accept that sexual infidelity should ever provide the basis for a partial defence to murder.

In practice, this means that in cases when words or conduct constituting sexual infidelity trigger the defendant’s loss of self-control in killing the victim, a jury is to disregard this evidence in deciding whether the conduct amounted to murder or manslaughter.

The Clinton case

One of the first cases to test the boundaries of the sexual infidelity provision was that of Jon Jacques Clinton. Clinton killed his wife in November 2010 after she allegedly admitted to having sex with multiple men and sniggered at the prospect of Clinton committing suicide as a result of their relationship breakdown.

Clinton had previously discovered messages on his wife’s Facebook profile containing sexual innuendos and discovered that her personal status was listed on Facebook as “separated”. It was these images, her listed status as well as her alleged admissions of sexual infidelity that Clinton argued led to his loss of self-control and use of lethal violence.

Clinton was convicted of murder as the trial judge determined that, given the new requirement to exclude evidence of sexual infidelity as a basis for a plea of loss of control, there was no other evidence to justify leaving the partial defence for the jury to consider.

On appeal, however, the Court of Appeal held that the provision does not wholly exclude evidence of sexual infidelity as irrelevant, where a defendant raises a plea of loss of control. The court stated that where sexual infidelity evidence is one part of a wider and more complex “provocation narrative”, the defendant can still raise a plea of loss of control. It will be where evidence of sexual infidelity is the sole basis for a plea of loss of self-control that the partial defence must fail.

The decision in Clinton has since raised concerns as to the ongoing likelihood of “jealous man” defences continuing to have credence in English law.

Sentencing

Beyond Clinton, the reforms also failed to significantly change the way English courts sentence jealous men who kill. Given the abolition of provocation, it was anticipated that such cases should fall into the category of murder. However, no guidance was provided on the extent to which evidence related to sexual infidelity should be influential in sentencing.

imageJustice has gender.From www.shutterstock.com

Our analysis of relevant murder cases since 2003 reveals that the English higher courts have regarded the change in law purely as a technical one, relevant only to the pre-conviction trial phase. Judges have not viewed the change in law as demanding a shift in moral thinking at sentencing.

Indeed, contrary to the spirit of the 2010 reforms, English judges have continued to view sexual infidelity evidence as having the potential to constitute grave provocation and justify a significantly lower term of imprisonment.

For example, in the 2011 case of Haywood, the defendant began a relationship with “W”, after his wife died. After they had bought a house together, W took a lover and later another lover, following which she informed the defendant that she was going to move in with her second lover. The defendant armed himself with an iron bar, attempted to disguise himself and fatally attacked W’s new partner.

Despite the 2010 reforms, on appeal the court stated that the case involved “the greatest possible provocation in the non-technical sense”. The defendant’s sentence was reduced to a minimum term of nine years.

This case, and others sentenced since the 2010 reforms, suggest that the courts have failed to incorporate the gender perspective of the 2010 reforms into sentencing practices.

Where to next?

Our research reveals that combating leniency in the law’s response for murders triggered by sexual infidelity is a task not yet achieved.

While the 2010 reforms have made some gains in improving the law’s response to the different contexts within which men and women kill, further review and reform is needed to ensure that the leniency previously afforded at the conviction stage is not merely transferred to sentencing.

The authors do not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article. They also have no relevant affiliations.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/five-years-after-the-end-of-provocation-jealous-male-killers-still-receive-leniency-42025

Business News

The Growing Demand for Durable Plastic Packaging Supplies Across Australia

Why Do Australian Businesses Need Reliable Plastic Packaging Supplies? Businesses need packaging that can withstand everyday handling, storage, and distribution without creating avoidable delays. Pla...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Choosing the Right Scope for Your Office

A well-planned office cleaning Melbourne arrangement starts with a clear understanding of the premises and the people who use it. An office may include private work areas, shared desks, reception, mee...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Businesses Can Prepare for Unexpected Power Outages

Power failures can occur quickly. The supply may be interrupted by bad weather, issues with the electricity network, damaged equipment or local construction work. This can be just a hassle for a fam...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Chatswood Tutoring Can Fit Into a Student’s Weekly Routine

Create a Predictable Weekly Structure A consistent weekly routine can make study easier to manage when students are balancing several subjects. Chatswood tutoring can provide a fixed learning point a...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

The Rise of Digital Marketplaces in the Australian Trade Sector

For decades, the Australian trade and construction sector operated almost entirely on word-of-mouth recommendations and local community networks. Small business owners typically relied on local newspa...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Immigration Lawyers Can Help

Introduction Visa decisions can shape employment, family life, study plans, travel, and future residence. A small omission can lead to delay, added expense, or refusal. Immigration lawyers assess l...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Industrial Drying Equipment Supports Efficient Processing

Many industrial processes require moisture to be removed from compressed air, products or process materials before they move to the next stage. Excess moisture can affect equipment performance, produc...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Practical Ways a Whiteboard Can Improve Workplace Communication

Effective communication helps teams stay organised, share ideas and keep track of important information. While digital tools are now common in many workplaces, a whiteboard continues to provide a simp...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Designing Eco-Friendly Custom Water Bottles for Your Next Event

The Evolution of Sustainable Event Merchandise Event planning has undergone a massive transformation over the last decade. Gone are the days when organizers could hand out cheap, single use plastic...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

The Daily Magazine

Work Boots vs Safety Shoes: Which Footwear Is Right for Your Workplace?

Not every job calls for a heavy pair of boots. Walk through a modern warehouse, factory floor or dis...

Master Bedroom Wall Decor Guide: Sizing, Layouts and Styling Ideas for Every Space

The main bedroom is often the last room in the house to get any attention. The living room gets the ...

What to Consider Before Installing a Built-In Wardrobe

Living in a modest home teaches you a lot. You learn how to keep a small kitchen tidy, where to hi...

Top 5 Mortgage Brokers in Sydney: How to Choose the Right One in 2027

Finding a mortgage broker in Sydney is not particularly difficult. Finding one who understands your ...

How Much Life Does Your Roof Have Left? Recognizing When Replacement Becomes Necessary

A roof can age quietly for years. From the street, everything may look reassuringly ordinary, even w...

How Australian Drivers Can Make Their Cars Harder to Steal

Most people don't think much about car theft until it happens to them, or to someone they know. Th...

The Short-Term Rental Rules Australian Owners Can’t Afford to Guess At

A holiday let looks simple from the outside: a spare property, a listing, some guests. Underneath ...

The Risks Of Removing Ear Wax Without Professional Guidance

Ear wax is an essential component of the hygiene process since it acts as a barrier between the ea...

Plumbing Call-Out Fees in Perth Explained

When you hire a plumber to fix a problem with a dripping tap, leaking pipe, or whatever it might be...