Daily BulletinDaily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation
imageAustralia's Future Fund, chaired by former Treasurer Peter Costello, is not immune to the tax schemes corporations love.Alan Porritt/AAP

A Senate inquiry on corporate tax avoidance this week will hear of the strange corporate structures used by companies such as News Corp, Google and Apple to euphemistically “optimise” their tax affairs. The companies and their tax advisers baulk at even the mention of the words “tax avoidance”.

However, while seemingly the optimisation tool of choice for News Corp and our big mining companies, the tax avoidance trick of setting up a shell company in an idyllic island or small European country and passing assets and income across its books is pretty old hat. Tax advisers today are using complex derivatives to massage money so that minimum, even better no, taxes have to be paid. These tax avoidance schemes involve not a hole in the wall in Luxembourg, but the very latest in financial engineering.

Taxation is a subject that makes even experts' eyes glaze over. Likewise, financial derivatives get very technical, very quickly. Put the two together and you have the makings of a very short-lived conversation. But it is a conversation that tax advisers love to have with their rich corporate clients, including large banks.

Derivatives are basically financial alchemy. If one has some money, or is about to come into some money, bankers will, for a nice fee, organise the flow of that money so that it precisely suits your needs, and if you manage to save a bit of tax in the process - so much the better.

One particular trick used by among others, Mitt Romney, is called a Total Return Swap (TRS). This particular magic wand is able to turn taxable dividends into capital gains taxed at a much lower level.

So how does tax come into the derivatives picture?

Close to home

One example of how such swaps are used is by our very own Future Fund, which has somehow managed to escape the gaze of Senators this week.

In a transaction involved in purchasing “distressed debt”, profits magically would be moved through a TRS from Luxembourg (a low taxing country) to the Cayman Islands (a no taxing country). Needless to say, Future Fund managing director David Neal was aghast that anyone would even suggest that such a complicated transaction was done to avoid tax. The Future Fund is now liable to pay income tax in Australia, but is subject to tax on profits in some foreign countries.

Banks and hedge funds are at the centre of this new alchemy, finding magical ways to turn income into capital gains or even better into expenses or tax losses.

How is it done?

It’s fiendishly complex (otherwise everyone would be doing it) but one way involves moving loans, guarantees and Interest Rate Swaps (of various types) between international companies in a spider’s web of cash payments, such that everyone wins but the tax authorities.

This is precisely what the Big Four Australian banks were found to have done when they settled with the New Zealand Inland Revenue Department (IRD) in December 2009 after being found guilty of creating “tax avoidance arrangements entered into for a purpose of avoiding tax”. This settlement of some A$1.7 billion was the largest legal settlement in Australian banking history. The irony of being found to have avoided paying taxes to the same taxpayers who had just guaranteed their safety in the global financial crisis appears to have been lost on the boards of Australian banks.

Much of the debate in the Senate Committee this week will deal quite rightly with shuffling of money between offshore tax havens or on company restructuring to minimise tax, but the future of tax avoidance is already out there and it’s not tax havens – it’s financial sorcery.

Dealing with complexity

More and smarter taxmen (and women) will be needed to deal with this complexity in future, at a time when the government is decimating their ranks at the Australian Taxation Office. Ironically, ATO staff are being replaced in some cases by external consultants, such as, you guessed it, PWC - yes the same PWC that thought up the Luxembourg schemes.

The European Union has recently enacted legislation curtailing the activities of audit firms with regard to tax advice. Australian Senators should consider similar legislation.

Pat will be on hand for an Author Q&A session between 10 and 11am AEST on Thursday April 9. Post your questions about the article in the comments section below.

Pat McConnell does not work for, consult to, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has no relevant affiliations.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/stopping-corporate-tax-avoidance-in-a-house-of-smoke-and-mirrors-39779

How to Better Study While Working


School is important, and so is staying safe from coronavirus. Here are some tips for returning seniors


The Conversation


Scott Morrison press conference July 16 2020

Good afternoon, everyone. The Australian economy is fighting back. The jobs of Australians depend on that fight. The incomes of Australians depend on that fight and we are in it and we are makin...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Scott Morrison Interview with Ray Hadley, 2GB

RAY HADLEY: Prime Minister, Scott Morrison, supposed to be on holidays. He's not. He's online. Prime Minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: G’day Ray. Certainly staying very close to every...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Scott Morrison Covid 19 update

PRIME MINISTER: Good afternoon, everyone. Today I’m joined by Professor Paul Murphy - sorry, Professor Paul Kelly. I’ve got Brendan Murphy still on the brain. You are not far from us, Brendan. B...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

What Are Your Basic Rights as an Employee and a Job Candidate?

There is no denying that we are living in very difficult times where finding stable employment is not that easy. However, no matter how harsh the circumstances are, people should not withstand m...

Diana Smith - avatar Diana Smith

Double the interest in eCommerce spaces from businesses after COVID-19 lockdown

Recent lockdown restrictions have emphasised the necessity of an eCommerce function in future-proofing retail businesses. Sydney-based co-working space, Workit Spaces, has seen double the amoun...

Steve Fletcher, National WHSQ Manager at Drake International - avatar Steve Fletcher, National WHSQ Manager at Drake International

Tips for Setting Up an E-Commerce Website

If you are fed up with the 9-5 daily grind and would like to make a living selling products online, setting up an e-commerce website might just be the answer. Many Australians have already freed t...

News Company - avatar News Company

News Company Media Core

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion