Thu Feb 9

How to save $4 billion a year: reform a fuel tax credit scheme with no real rationale

Written by: Marion Terrill, Transport and Cities Program Director, Grattan Institute

Revising the generous fuel tax credits given to businesses should be a priority for the Albanese government, because keeping them would conflict with two other pressing priorities: reducing carbon emissions and repairing the budget.

Fuel tax exemptions have existed for as long as the federal government has taxed fuel, starting in 1957. With the rationale for the tax being to pay for building and maintaining roads, initially all off-road users were exempt.

But the earmarking of all fuel tax revenue for spending on roads ended in 1959 – more than 60 years ago. With the tax becoming a general revenue-raiser, the rationale for exemptions or tax credits has shifted with the disposition of the government of the day.

The settings inherited by the Albanese government now cost the budget almost $8 billion a year.

CC BY As long ago as 1991, the Australian National Audit Office recommended the credit scheme “clarify its purpose and objectives”. Yet those objectives remain unclear today. Who benefits most? Previous governments have argued exemptions and tax credits support regional industries, and people living in regional areas. In 1999, when the credit was extended to marine, rail, and some trucks and buses, the then-deputy prime minister (and National Party leader) John Anderson said the goal was to reduce transport costs, particularly for “those people living in regional, rural and remote areas”. In 2006, when expanding the credit to include all off-road users and on-road vehicles weighing over 4.5 tonnes, the then-assistant treasurer Peter Dutton said: “This is good news for business, and regional Australia in particular.” But if the aim of the policy is to support regional areas, fuel tax credits are a poorly targeted way to do so. Read more: We pay billions to subsidise Australia’s fossil fuel industry. This makes absolutely no economic sense In the five industries that receive almost 90% of the value of credits, more than 60% of businesses, and 67% of employees, are in major cities. There is no evidence fuel tax credits particularly benefit regional areas, or that they are more effective than other policies in doing so. It is hard to avoid the conclusion that fuel tax credits are mostly a gift to the mining and agricultural industries – the only non-care industries that have always received an exemption from paying taxes on fuel, and the major recipients of fuel tax credits today.

Business in the mining, transport and agriculture industries are biggest recipients of fuel tax credits.

CC BY-SA Budgetary needs have prompted changes Changes to fuel tax credits have also aligned with the budgetary needs of the government of the day. In 1982, when government debt as a share of GDP was rising steadily, the Fraser government narrowed the scheme to just mining, primary industries and care industries. Many businesses previously exempt – including in rail, marine, construction and manufacturing – were forced to pay fuel taxes. In 2006, the Howard government broadened the scheme during the mining boom when budget surpluses meant no net debt for the first time in 30 years. Despite the straightened fiscal position the government now faces, the credit scheme remains unchanged. Out of step with net zero and budget repair The Albanese government has several growing spending obligations, particularly in health, aged care, disability care and interest expenses on its debt. After stripping out the effects of temporary factors such as high commodity prices, there remains a stubborn gap between government receipts and spending of about $40 billion a year. In a new report published by Grattan Institute, Fuelling budget repair: How to reform fuel taxes for business, we argue fuel tax credits should be removed for on-road users, and roughly halved for off-road users. This would save about $4 billion a year. It would also reflect the environmental and health costs of diesel use. Read more: Australia's government gives more support to fossil fuel research than is apparent Giving businesses tax credits on for consuming fuel without having to pay for or reduce their carbon emissions is sharply at odds with the government’s goal of net zero emissions by 2050. Diesel combustion currently accounts for 17% of Australia’s emissions. In 2020, the top five industry recipients of fuel tax credits directly produced more than half of Australia’s emissions. That share is expected to reach 64% by 2030. As well as helping repair the budget, reducing fuel tax credits would signal to businesses that they need to consider emissions in their investment decisions, minimising the costs to future consumers, taxpayers and shareholders. Authors: Marion Terrill, Transport and Cities Program Director, Grattan Institute

How to save $4 billion a year: reform a fuel tax credit scheme with no real rationale

The Hidden Pitfalls of Owning a Holiday Rental in Australia - and How Professional Management Pays for Itself

Why More Property Buyers Are Getting Expert Help Before Making an Offer

What Makes Buyers Take a Property Listing Seriously?

When Should You Hire a Construction Lawyer for an Adjudication Matter in Australia

Business News

The Rise of Digital Marketplaces in the Australian Trade Sector

How Immigration Lawyers Can Help

How Industrial Drying Equipment Supports Efficient Processing

Practical Ways a Whiteboard Can Improve Workplace Communication

Designing Eco-Friendly Custom Water Bottles for Your Next Event

Why Choosing a Professional Florist Melbourne Makes Flower Delivery Impactful

The Business Case for Choosing Australian Fabricators Over Imported Alternatives

Australian organisations are relying on business continuity plans built for a far more predictable world

How to Rent a Car for Uber in Melbourne: What Every New Driver Needs to Know

The Daily Magazine

Microsoft Surface For Business (Microsoft 365 E3, E5, E7) And Modern Workplace Requirements

Choosing the Right Split System for Melbourne Homes

What Happens to Remaining Sperm Stored in the Vas Deferens After the Procedure

Top Tips on Combining TMS Therapy with Comprehensive Adult ADHD Care in Sydney

What To Expect Before, During, And After Laser And CRP Hair Loss Treatments

What To Ask During A Consultation For Men's Hair Loss Treatment And PRP

How to Ensure Safe and On-Time Building Material Delivery with Sydney Cargo Transportation Services

What to Ask Your Cosmetic Surgeon About Liposuction and Thigh Lift Reduction in Perth

Top Ergonomic Tips to Enhance Your Neck Pain Treatment and Prevent Back Pain In Sydney