Daily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation
imageThe controversy over Speaker Bronwyn Bishop's entitlements row continues to dominate the news cycle.Mick Tsikas/AAP

The finance department, asked by the Australian Federal Police (AFP) to investigate Bronwyn Bishop’s A$5227 helicopter ride between Melbourne and Geelong, now finds itself sitting on a very hot seat.

If the department decides Bishop breached the entitlement rules, the question becomes whether this is referred back to the AFP for formal investigation or is accepted as a mistake.

If, however, finance concludes she was within the speaker’s entitlement when she claimed for attending a state election fundraiser, the government will be under heavy pressure to amend the rules which, it seems, are wide and woolly.

The opposition has questioned the AFP’s decision to refer the issue on, arguing that its refusal to investigate the allegations against Bishop would be inconsistent with the approach taken to allegations against one of her predecessors, Peter Slipper.

The police are anxious not to be seen to be avoiding their duty. A spokesperson said the AFP had “not refused to investigate” but had sent the matter to finance for assessment in accordance with the so-called Minchin protocol on dealing with alleged breaches of entitlements.

This protocol was approved by then-special minister of state Nick Minchin in 1998.

Under it, when an allegation of misuse is made, the finance department investigates. If the matter is minor, the MP gets a please explain.

If more serious, the matter goes to a high-level departmental committee chaired by the department’s secretary (currently Jane Halton). This committee may or may not seek an explanation from the parliamentarian.

If it considers the matter possibly criminal, or is unclear about questions of law, the committee will obtain advice from the secretary of the attorney-general’s department as to whether it warrants referral to the AFP.

The finance secretary makes the final decision on a referral, but in practice this would be on the advice of the attorney-general’s department secretary.

The Minchin protocol is supposed to allow politicians to fix up mistakes, as well as to put the entitlements process at arm’s length from the politicians.

But the difficulties of asking bureaucrats to rule on their political masters are obvious. It would be better if the initial investigations were done by some independent tribunal.

Also, if the rules are found to cover such a claim as Bishop’s (forget that she’s repaying, which would not have happened without the fuss) then they should be tightened. But any workable rules will always be, to an extent, hostage to the integrity of those making the claims.

The AFP has addressed the suggested difference in treatment in the Slipper issue by saying that it received a referral “along with associated information” to investigate fraud allegations. It said this referral did not come from the finance department. “Material relating to this matter was sought from finance, which provided it to the AFP.”

Bishop – who has asked that two other charters she ordered also be considered (not helicopters) – continues to insist her claim was within the rules, essentially daring anyone to prove that it was not.

“I was a guest speaker. I find it unconscionable for you to think there are certain people in the Australian community that are not entitled to hear from members of parliament,” Bishop said defiantly.

“I’m speaking about the parliament and how it works and that’s what I did.” (No recording of what she spoke about has surfaced.)

Meanwhile Bishop subtly rearranges her story. “Whilst my understanding is that this travel was conducted within the rules, to avoid any doubt, I will reimburse the full costs,” she said last week. Now she is saying: “it was done within the entitlement. When I saw that figure, I saw it was too large and that’s why I’m repaying it.”

Bishop has not indicated any other activities around this event which were more “official”. Yet a while ago Tony Abbott explained his lateness to a partyroom meeting by saying he had attended a function that morning to justify claiming a trip to Melbourne for a party fundraiser the night before.

Abbott, who has had to repay claims in the past, is standing behind the embattled speaker. “Look, the important thing is that Bronwyn has admitted that it was probably an error of judgement and she has repaid the money,” he said on Saturday.

But Bill Shorten, no doubt crossing fingers that the Liberals don’t discover any embarrassing Labor claims, is continuing to escalate the attack. “Does Mr Abbott have the character to tell Bronwyn Bishop to stand aside?” Shorten said on Sunday. “Because he knows and the world knows that this arrogant misuse of taxpayer funds needs to be held to account.”

Bishop and Abbott are gambling that the rules on entitlements will be too broad for the speaker to be declared in breach, and that the news cycle will move on after a couple more days.

On the other hand, some see the helicopter ride as one of those lightning rods that will continue to seriously outrage the public, a less dramatic version of the knighthood for Prince Philip.

Listen to the newest Politics with Michelle Grattan podcast, with French Ambassador Christophe Lecourtier, here.

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/the-ultimate-horror-for-public-servants-judging-bronwyn-bishop-44889

Writers Wanted

Diverse spokespeople and humour: how the government's next ad campaign could boost COVID vaccine uptake


Let's talk about what each uni does, but don't make it a choice between teaching or research


The Advantages Of Using Betting Apps in Australia


The Conversation


Prime Minister interview with Karl Stefanovic and Allison Langdon

Karl Stefanovic: PM, good morning to you. Do you have blood on your hands?   PRIME MINISTER: No, it's obviously absurd. What we're doing here is we've got a temporary pause in place because we'v...

Karl Stefanovic and Allison Langdon - avatar Karl Stefanovic and Allison Langdon

Prime Minister Scott Morrison delivered Keynote Address at AFR Business Summit

Well, thank you all for the opportunity to come and be with you here today. Can I also acknowledge the Gadigal people, the Eora Nation, the elders past and present and future. Can I also acknowled...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Morrison Government commits record $9B to social security safety net

The Morrison Government is enhancing our social security safety net by increasing support for unemployed Australians while strengthening their obligations to search for work.   From March the ...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

Boom in Aussies buying up restaurants, pubs, hotels and bars in regional centres

With international borders closed, regional Australia is seeing a dramatic surge in popularity as people move out of the cities and into their quaint communities. City slickers are looking for new...

Tess Sanders Lazarus - avatar Tess Sanders Lazarus

5 Signs Your Business Needs Onboarding Software

Onboarding software is the technology that automates a smooth transition for new hires from before the interview to the first day on the job. High-quality onboarding platforms feature a digital da...

Onboarded - avatar Onboarded

What Is COVID 19 Risk Assessment for Vulnerable Workers and Why Your Business Needs it

During the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, governments strongly advised people to just stay at home as a critical effort to stop the spread of the virus. This led to many businesses temporarily s...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com