Abbott scores big win on party reform as Coalition continues to trail in Newspoll
- Written by Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra
The Abbott forces are seeking to drive home their sweeping Sunday victory in winning rank and file endorsement for reforming the NSW Liberal party by putting a three-month deadline on the changes being ratified.
A special convention of party members voted overwhelmingly for motions from the former prime minister’s Warringah federal electorate conference (FEC) backing plebiscites for preselecting all candidates and direct election by the party members of those who run the party organisation.
This comes as the latest Newspoll, published in The Australian, shows the Coalition continuing to trail Labor 47-53% in two party terms. This is the 16th consecutive Newspoll in which the government has been behind.
The Coalition’s primary vote rose a point to 36%, while Labor also rose a point, to 37%. One Nation slipped from 11% to 9%; the Greens fell from 10% to 9% since the last poll a fortnight ago.
Malcolm Turnbull’s net satisfaction improved 4 points to minus 20; Bill Shorten’s net satisfaction was static on minus 20. Turnbull widened his lead as better prime minister from 8 points to 11 points.
At the convention of NSW Liberal party members, the plebiscite motion was passed by 748 votes to 476, and the accompanying motion by a two to one margin.
The endorsement of the “Warringah” model is a huge challenge to the factional grip of the state division held by the moderates and soft right.
The changes would likely see the division move to the right, in line with the political colour of its rank and file, and make it harder for moderates to win preselections.
But the reforms have to be approved by the state council before they take effect. Given the majorities on the key votes were so decisive, and backing crossed factional lines, it would be hard for the current power brokers to resist the general thrust. But there could be a struggle ahead over timing and detail.
Walter Villatora, president of the Warringah FEC, said after the two day meeting: “These reforms now need to be ratified, which I expect will happen within 3-months.”
“Somewhere up above in Liberal Party heaven Robert Menzies is looking down and smiling. The party membership have clearly spoken. The era of brutal factionalism is over”, he said. “The NSW Liberal Party is now the most democratic division in Australia.”
But a statement by State president Kent Johns suggested there would not be any rush. “The convention result reflected the members’ desire to reform some of our organisation’s internal processes, and serves as a clear demonstration of participation by our membership”, he said.
“Members showed their support for introducing a plebiscite model to ensure that the NSW Liberal party continues to preselect the best candidates …
"Discussions at the convention will inform the development of the party’s modernisation plan, which will be prepared by me and the state director, Chris Stone. Constitutional amendments will be prepared over the coming months by our constitutional committee, and proceed to the party’s governing body – state council”.
Turnbull positioned himself carefully in his address to the convention on Saturday so as not to be caught in the firing line if the Abbott push won.
He stressed his support for plebiscites, saying every member should have a say in selecting candidates. It was widely believed, however, that he would have preferred a more circumscribed model.
But the convention voted down or didn’t reach motions attempting to impose some restrictions. These included having a longer eligibility period and an “activity test” before members could vote, and the grandfathering of electorates with sitting members.
In the Warringah model the only condition on party members voting in the plebiscites would be that they must have been a member for two years.
The present preselection system has candidates chosen by panels comprising local delegates and non-local members.
Neither Turnbull nor premier Gladys Berejiklian were at the convention when the vote was taken.
Later a spokeswoman for Turnbull said that as the Prime Minister had said at the convention, “he has long supported that all Liberal party members have a direct say in preselections. The PM wants to ensure that every member of the party knows that their voice is heard and respected.
"The PM made it clear yesterday that plebiscites for preselections are a good idea, but hardly a new one. Every other Liberal party division has adopted them,” she said.
Abbott emailed members in his electorate: “This is a great advance for our party - and it would not have happened without the hard work of the Warringah conference led by our president, Walter Villatora.
"There’s more to do, of course. Democratisation now has to run the gauntlet of state council; but this is potentially a wonderful new start for our party. A revitalised, less factionalised party will be really important to winning the next election.
"This is a big "thank you” to all Warringah Liberals. Let’s now do our best to build on this success.“
Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra