Daily BulletinDaily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation
imageSteam power. Do railway unions have a unique advantage in pay deals?Dazzie D, CC BY

News this week that the Rail, Maritime and Transport (RMT) union had called off threatened strike action on the railways undoubtedly came as a welcome relief to many travellers, workers and managers. The RMT is now considering a sharply increased pay offer and a “job security package” after some nail-biting negotiations. It might be less heartening news, however, to other public sector workers whose unions have delivered less.

Transport unions tend to have much higher profile than others, simply because their work has such an impact on everyone’s lives. This gives the RMT the strength and profile that workers and unions in most other occupations simply do not have. Its success though should get us thinking whether some of the tactics it has used could work in other sectors.

Selling points

So what advantages does the RMT have? It organises in a sector that affects almost everyone. Rail commuting in London is common, across the spectrum of professions. That means that a very wide range of people and businesses are disrupted during any rail strike and public pressure to resolve the problems builds very quickly.

Safety standards are also extremely important to both the companies that provide services and to the customers who use them, so it is very difficult to replace rail workers with untrained staff if they take industrial action. Also, the range of occupations in the rail industry is relatively small and focused on one key goal; making the trains run safely and on time. As a result, strong solidarities develop that transfer over into union membership.

With that background, it’s not surprising that RMT negotiators have a strong hand to play in bargaining meetings. Even the threat of action can create public concern that adds to the urgency of reaching a deal. So could that be reproduced in other sectors? Well in all honesty, probably not.

Burnt offerings

Firefighters are probably the most similar to rail workers in that they also work closely together, in highly trained jobs and with a strong public focus – in this case on ensuring effective fire cover. But firefighters face the problem that if they withdraw their services entirely, the consequences could be catastrophic – and deadly. Rail workers are only inconveniencing us when they strike.

This means that deals are often done to make sure that essential cover is in place during rare strikes by the Fire Brigades Union. It may be the right thing to do, but it dilutes the strike impact and muddies the waters for negotiation.

imageFighting fire with fire. Possibly foolish.UK Ministry of Defence, CC BY-NC

Meanwhile, workers in sectors or occupations where a strike would cause minimal disruption have increasingly found that the very serious legal hurdles aimed at limiting strike action usually mean that the “costs” outweigh the potential “benefits”. The simple calculation is one of the main reasons why we have seen such a fall in strike action in recent years.

United front

So if strikes are difficult, disruptive and costly for everyone, how can the collective process of negotiating terms and conditions of work be effective? After all, this is one of the main reasons for unions to exist: to bargain for a group of workers over their terms and conditions of employment: pay, holidays, training and the like. Collective bargaining has a fundamental rationale: it takes away the danger that managers treat individual workers arbitrarily and makes sure that the rules of the game are clear to both sides.

Historically, the ultimate “threat” in the bargaining process has been to stop work. Unions could threaten strike action and employers could threaten to lock workers out of the workplace. Both mean that workers take a (hopefully) short-term hit to their pay, in the hope that the benefits of the eventual collective agreement improve things enough to offset that hit.

But eventually work has to restart and the two sides have to rub along together again. As a result, it is rare to find a negotiator from either side who thinks it is a good idea to let negotiations get to a position of using the “nuclear option”.

imageNon-flying pickets. A reference for the kids there.Roger Blackwell, CC BY

Today in the UK, as a result of legal changes in the 1980s and 1990s, strike action is hard to take within the legislative constraints. As a result, collective bargaining in the UK has changed. The difficult of calling a strike means that it can be used in a more targeted way and means that if a union wins a ballot for strike action, both sides know that there is a real strength of feeling about the issue.

That in turn reinforces the hand of the union negotiators and – as happened with the RMT – often helps ensure a deal is done before the first declared strike day. The rail workers may have other advantages at their disposal, as we discussed above, but the most powerful might be their simple willingness to walk out. The flip-side of this, of course, is that where strike action is harder to organise, so collective bargaining can lose its power.

Rare beast

There is a broader concern here too: collective bargaining, when it works, remains one of the most effective ways of reducing inequality across an economy as a whole. As the UK has made union representation and collective bargaining more and more difficult, the difference between the lowest and highest-paid workers has increased dramatically, bringing with it a lot of social problems.

Although there are some high-profile examples of strike threats – and even some successful strike action – these are increasingly rare and dependent on a specific set of factors that increase the influence of workers and their unions at key moments in time such as is the case with the RMT.

Looking to the future, proposed new laws mean that unions are likely to face even greater constraints on strike ballots. Collective bargaining will carry on because it makes sense in many large organisations; it gives a legitimacy to the way pay is decided. But the likelihood is that we will probably see even less evidence of strike threats in future, and brinkmanship of the type the RMT pulled off this week will become ever more rare.

Melanie Simms receives funding from a range of organisations, including unions and the Trades Union Congress. She is a member of the University and Colleges Union (UCU).

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/rail-workers-union-strikes-a-blow-for-collective-bargaining-42706

Friday essay: need a sitter? Revisiting girlhood, feminism and diversity in The Baby-Sitters Club


Did a tragic family secret influence Kate Sheppard's mission to give New Zealand women the vote?


The Conversation


Prime Minister Interview with Ben Fordham, 2GB

FORDHAM: Thank you very much for talking to us. I know it's a difficult day for all of those Qantas workers. Look, they want to know in the short term, are you going to extend JobKeeper?   PRI...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Scott Morrison interview with Neil Mitchell

NEIL MITCHELL: Prime minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, how are you?   MICHELL: I’m okay, a bit to get to I apologise, we haven't spoken for a while and I want to get t...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Interview with Ben Fordham

PRIME MINISTER: I've always found that this issue on funerals has been the hardest decision that was taken and the most heartbreaking and of all the letters and, you know, there's been over 100...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

SEO In A Time of COVID-19: A Life-Saver

The coronavirus pandemic has brought about a lot of uncertainty for everyone across the world. It has had one of the most devastating impacts on the day-to-day lives of many including business o...

a Guest Writer - avatar a Guest Writer

5 Ways Risk Management Software Can Help Your Business

No business is averse to risks. Nobody can predict the future or even plan what direction a business is going to take with 100% accuracy. For this reason, to avoid issues or minimise risks, some for...

News Company - avatar News Company

5 Ways To Deal With Unemployment and Get Back Into the Workforce

Being unemployed has a number of challenges and they’re not all financial. It can affect you psychologically and sometimes it can be difficult to dig your way out of a rut when you don’t have a job ...

News Company - avatar News Company

News Company Media Core

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion