Daily BulletinDaily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation Contributor

The government has released Treasury modelling showing a tax mix switch with a 15% GST and income tax cuts would deliver no gains to economic growth.

The modelling has been put out to back up Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s decision to walk away from the GST change on the grounds that the option, as he told the Coalition party room on Tuesday, “does not offer the economic benefits that many have assumed”.

As a result of the modelling the government has refocused its work on its tax package towards other options.

The modelling, presented in a January 25 Treasury ministerial brief, assumed an increase in the GST from 10% to 15%, and broadening its base to include water and sewerage. This would raise $35 billion. It further assumed $6 billion in assistance to households automatically generated from indexed pension payments, leaving the rest for income tax cuts.

The higher GST rate would cut 1.2% off GDP, and the automatic CPI indexation of transfer payments and grants would slice off another 0.1%, according to the modelling. The modest base broadening to water and sewerage would add 0.07%, while the income tax cuts would add 1.3%. This left a bottom line of no addition to GDP.

The assumption in the modelling about compensation is minimalist – further measures would be needed in practice to compensate low income earners, which would mean less funds available for income tax cuts.

The government tested the Treasury modelling against that from two private sector firms – Independent Economics and KPMG. They came up with tiny increases to GDP from such a package.

Independent Economics estimated 0.18% gain to GDP in the long term, while KPMG’s estimate was 0.3% gain.

The brief says: “The estimates from the scenario testing are, of course, indicative and may change with further refinement.

“That said, they are all pointing to a small increase in GDP over time from personal income tax reductions that are funded largely by a GST hike. In essence, the models all suggest they are largely offsetting.”

The brief notes that the impact would be greater the more personal income tax cuts were combined with corporate income tax cuts – but the government could not, in political terms, skew its tax cuts to the corporate sector.

“The case [for a tax mix switch] will need to be made forcefully using broader arguments. These include the impetus to entrepreneurial behaviour, international competitiveness and reducing incentives to channel personal income into company and other structures,” the brief says.

Treasury also provided a brief on the economic and fiscal effects of rising average tax rates (bracket creep).

Dated February 1, it says that by the end of the forward estimates, about half of the fiscal consolidation relies on increases in average tax rates due to the tax scales not being indexed.

The average personal income tax rate is set to be 24.4% in 2016-17, rising to 26.6% by 2020-21.

Treasury has modelled the economic cost of allowing average tax rates to rise over the forward estimates period.

It shows that achieving a deficit reduction through an increase in the average tax rate, compared with a strategy of maintaining a constant average tax rate and cutting government spending, leads to a 0.35% contraction in GDP in the long term.

The long term economic cost of the increase in average tax rates (0.55% of GDP) is only partly offset by the lift in economic activity from government spending (0.2% of GDP).

The brief cautions that this modelling is indicative at best but says “it does illustrate the economic cost of relying on bracket creep, rather than spending cuts to close the budget deficit”.

“The economic cost of rising average tax rates is large (0.55% of GDP) because it creates distortions in all sectors of the economy. The economic distortion from all taxes increases as personal income tax rates rise.”

Industry Minister Christopher Pyne told Parliament on Thursday “there won’t be a [higher] goods and services tax”.

Authors: The Conversation Contributor

Read more http://theconversation.com/treasury-modelling-shows-no-growth-lift-from-gst-tax-mix-switch-54574

Friday essay: need a sitter? Revisiting girlhood, feminism and diversity in The Baby-Sitters Club

arrow_forward

Did a tragic family secret influence Kate Sheppard's mission to give New Zealand women the vote?

arrow_forward

The Conversation
INTERWEBS DIGITAL AGENCY

Politics

Prime Minister Interview with Ben Fordham, 2GB

FORDHAM: Thank you very much for talking to us. I know it's a difficult day for all of those Qantas workers. Look, they want to know in the short term, are you going to extend JobKeeper?   PRI...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Scott Morrison interview with Neil Mitchell

NEIL MITCHELL: Prime minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, how are you?   MICHELL: I’m okay, a bit to get to I apologise, we haven't spoken for a while and I want to get t...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Interview with Ben Fordham

PRIME MINISTER: I've always found that this issue on funerals has been the hardest decision that was taken and the most heartbreaking and of all the letters and, you know, there's been over 100...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

SEO In A Time of COVID-19: A Life-Saver

The coronavirus pandemic has brought about a lot of uncertainty for everyone across the world. It has had one of the most devastating impacts on the day-to-day lives of many including business o...

a Guest Writer - avatar a Guest Writer

5 Ways Risk Management Software Can Help Your Business

No business is averse to risks. Nobody can predict the future or even plan what direction a business is going to take with 100% accuracy. For this reason, to avoid issues or minimise risks, some for...

News Company - avatar News Company

5 Ways To Deal With Unemployment and Get Back Into the Workforce

Being unemployed has a number of challenges and they’re not all financial. It can affect you psychologically and sometimes it can be difficult to dig your way out of a rut when you don’t have a job ...

News Company - avatar News Company



News Company Media Core

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion