Business Blockbuster - Helpng business to be more visible on Google

Daily Bulletin

Are judges in South Africa under threat or do they complain too much?

  • Written by: The Conversation
imageSouth African President Jacob Zuma, right, listens to Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng ahead of Zuma's second inauguration in Pretoria.Reuters/Siphiwe Sibeko

Next week, South African President Jacob Zuma will sit down with its chief justice for an unprecedented, potentially watershed discussion.

It would be fascinating to be a fly on the wall to observe how the country’s two most important constitutional office-holders handle a very sensitive conversation about a very delicate topic: judicial independence.

The meeting, set for August 27, was requested by Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng after an extraordinary meeting of senior judges. They are concerned by what they call the “general gratuitous criticism” of the judiciary by members of the South African cabinet.

The judges were quick to indicate that they welcomed criticism. But, they said, it should be specific and clear. Mogoeng told the media that the rule of law was the cornerstone of South Africa’s constitutional democracy and that everyone was bound by the constitution and the law. “As a nation, we ignore it at our peril,” the judges said in a statement.

South Africa’s Constitution empowers its Constitutional Court to overturn government law or policy when it infringes the Constitution. The court did this in 2002 when it declared the then-president Thabo Mbeki administration’s quixotic refusal to provide life-saving anti-retroviral drugs to AIDS patients as unreasonable.

The court said the government’s action was a breach of its duty in terms of the Constitution. Tensions are probably inevitable in any constitutional democracy that gives the courts the power to overrule the executive and legislative branches of government. Unsurprisingly, freely and fairly elected governments with big majorities don’t much like being overturned by a small group of unelected judges.

So are the judges’ concerns justified or are they being unnecessarily thin-skinned?

Importance of the rule of law

South Africa’s economy is stuck in a rut with growth sorely undermined by an electricity crisis. Its former powerhouse mining sector is hurting badly from low global commodity prices and other structural constraints.

Given this, South Africa needs to be mindful, and protective, of its strategic assets. The rule of law is one such strategic asset because it provides South Africa with a comparative competitive advantage.

One thing investors choosing between emerging markets such as Brazil, Russia, Turkey, Indonesia and South Africa pay close attention to is the quality of the rule of law. It matters for several reasons:

  • contractual integrity;

  • preservation of intellectual property;

  • level-playing field market competition; and

  • health and safety compliance – to name but a few.

An emerging market asset manager put it even more crisply to me in January, explaining his decision to move R300 million (about US$23m) of his client’s money from Russia to South Africa:

Zuma may be a problem, but I know that unlike Putin, he’s not going to lock up any of your CEOs for some egregious or capricious reason.

South Africa has a strong bench of capable, honest judges, at the top of a legal system that is served by a well-developed legal profession. The profession, in general, more than matches the professional excellence of its corporate leadership.

Investors, as well as many citizens and civil society pressure groups, can avail themselves of the law with confidence. They know that unlike in many parts of the world, they will get their day in court. And their case will be decided on the merits and not on the basis of the size of the bribe paid to the presiding judge.

Judiciary under fire

In 2012, Zuma spoke about the need to “review the powers of the Constitutional Court”. The broader legal and constitution-watching fraternity got anxious – not least because Zuma himself has a significant vested interest.

A judicial review challenge to the decision to drop serious corruption charges against Zuma in March 2009, shortly before his election as president, is wending its way through the courts.

Also, the secretary-general of the governing ANC, Gwede Mantashe, has referred to the judges as “counter-revolutionaries”. The quixotic remark suggests he thinks the judicial branch of government has a duty to interpret the law in a certain direction. But, adjudicating without fear or favour is the fundamental pillar of judicial independence.

Things have deteriorated further during the course of a three-year long battle that has pitted Zuma and the ANC against and the country’s Public Protector, Advocate Thuli Madonsela.

imageSouth Africa’s Public Protector Thuli Madonsela made adverse findings against the president.The Star

This followed Madonsela finding that Zuma had unlawfully benefited through public expenditure on his private homestead at Nkandla. The scandal has dominated the political discourse in recent times and led to violent scenes in parliament.

Backed by loyal MPs, Zuma has refused to accept Madonsela’s findings. This is further evidence that Zuma and his party are increasingly disregarding the Constitution. It also shows their eagerness to intimidate or insult constitutional bodies, including the judiciary.

This trend then found expression in the Judicial Service Commission (JSC), the constitutional body that appoints judges. Its membership includes several members of the ANC, who have become increasingly preoccupied with “separation of powers” in recent years.

This is a euphemism for their growing preference for non-activist judges who will more likely defer to the executive. This is evident when questioning candidates for judicial appointment in the twice-annual public interviews conducted by the body.

Observers such as the University of Cape Town’s Democratic Governance & Rights Unit feared a “partisan takeover” of the JSC. On one occasion last year, an ANC MP and deputy minister, Fatima Chohan, asked a candidate whether his background in human rights meant that he would be biased against the government. This from a representative of the party with a once-proud record of defending human rights against the brutal assault of apartheid authoritarianism.

Judges fight back

But the straw that broke the camel’s back as far as Mogoeng and his senior colleagues were concerned was when when the government blatantly misled the court, and then disobeyed its order to arrest Sudanese President Omar Al-Bashir. The fugitive from international law for crimes against humanity was in South Africa to attend an African Union summit.

Zuma issued a proclamation granting Bashir immunity but as the court said this could not trump either the statute affirming South Africa’s ratification of the International Criminal Court (ICC) treaty nor the court’s own order that the ICC arrest warrant be executed by the South African government.

As the government’s advocate played for time in court, Bashir was happily flying back home, rendering the judgment of the Pretoria High Court an exercise in futility and enraging the usually mild-mannered Judge President of the division, Dunstan Mlambo, which led to the extraordinary meeting of the judges.

In time, the incident may be seen as the start of a descent towards authoritarianism. Or South Africa’s robust rule of law will fight back. Next week’s meeting between president and chief justice represents a fork in the road.

Richard Calland is affiliated with the Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution (Casac).

Authors: The Conversation

Read more http://theconversation.com/are-judges-in-south-africa-under-threat-or-do-they-complain-too-much-45459

Business News

The Growing Demand for Durable Plastic Packaging Supplies Across Australia

Why Do Australian Businesses Need Reliable Plastic Packaging Supplies? Businesses need packaging that can withstand everyday handling, storage, and distribution without creating avoidable delays. Pla...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Office Cleaning Melbourne: Choosing the Right Scope for Your Office

A well-planned office cleaning Melbourne arrangement starts with a clear understanding of the premises and the people who use it. An office may include private work areas, shared desks, reception, mee...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Businesses Can Prepare for Unexpected Power Outages

Power failures can occur quickly. The supply may be interrupted by bad weather, issues with the electricity network, damaged equipment or local construction work. This can be just a hassle for a fam...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Chatswood Tutoring Can Fit Into a Student’s Weekly Routine

Create a Predictable Weekly Structure A consistent weekly routine can make study easier to manage when students are balancing several subjects. Chatswood tutoring can provide a fixed learning point a...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

The Rise of Digital Marketplaces in the Australian Trade Sector

For decades, the Australian trade and construction sector operated almost entirely on word-of-mouth recommendations and local community networks. Small business owners typically relied on local newspa...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Immigration Lawyers Can Help

Introduction Visa decisions can shape employment, family life, study plans, travel, and future residence. A small omission can lead to delay, added expense, or refusal. Immigration lawyers assess l...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Industrial Drying Equipment Supports Efficient Processing

Many industrial processes require moisture to be removed from compressed air, products or process materials before they move to the next stage. Excess moisture can affect equipment performance, produc...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Practical Ways a Whiteboard Can Improve Workplace Communication

Effective communication helps teams stay organised, share ideas and keep track of important information. While digital tools are now common in many workplaces, a whiteboard continues to provide a simp...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Designing Eco-Friendly Custom Water Bottles for Your Next Event

The Evolution of Sustainable Event Merchandise Event planning has undergone a massive transformation over the last decade. Gone are the days when organizers could hand out cheap, single use plastic...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

The Daily Magazine

How Much Life Does Your Roof Have Left? Recognizing When Replacement Becomes Necessary

A roof can age quietly for years. From the street, everything may look reassuringly ordinary, even w...

How Australian Drivers Can Make Their Cars Harder to Steal

Most people don't think much about car theft until it happens to them, or to someone they know. Th...

The Short-Term Rental Rules Australian Owners Can’t Afford to Guess At

A holiday let looks simple from the outside: a spare property, a listing, some guests. Underneath ...

The Risks Of Removing Ear Wax Without Professional Guidance

Ear wax is an essential component of the hygiene process since it acts as a barrier between the ea...

Plumbing Call-Out Fees in Perth Explained

When you hire a plumber to fix a problem with a dripping tap, leaking pipe, or whatever it might be...

Workshop Tool Maintenance: A Practical Guide to Drills, Sanders and Table Saws

A drill that strips every screw head. A sander that leaves swirl marks however long you work the pan...

How Architecture and Engineering Firms Can Improve Project Profitability

Project profitability remains one of the most persistent challenges for architecture and engineering...

The Blossoming World of Fresh Flower Delivery: An In-Depth Exploration

In recent years, the demand for fresh flower delivery in Sydney has soared, driven in part by the ...

How Penrith SMEs Can Keep Stock and Equipment Working for the Business

For Penrith SMEs in 2026, efficient inventory starts with reliable stock data: what is on hand, wher...