..


The Conversation

  • Written by Geoff Masters, CEO, Australian Council for Educational Research

NAPLAN testing starts this week. With calls for a review, many education experts are calling the Future of NAPLAN into question. In this series, the experts look at options for removing, replacing, rethinking or resuming NAPLAN.

The National Assessment Program - Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) has now been in place for a decade. Some 4.5 million young Australians between the ages of nine and 24 have taken NAPLAN tests at some point during their schooling.

But NAPLAN has its critics and, as with all testing programs, would benefit from ongoing review and refinement.

Here are two suggestions that might make these tests more useful to classroom teaching and learning.

Read more: Classroom design should follow evidence, not architectural fads

Abandon public comparisons of school results

In common with the state-based tests (for example, the NSW Basic Skills Test) it replaced, NAPLAN was introduced to provide parents, teachers and schools with objective information about students’ foundational literacy and numeracy skills.

This was after unacceptably low levels of reading and numeracy were going undetected and unaddressed in Australian schools.

We need to reform NAPLAN to make it more useful NAPLAN testing has reportedly led to inappropriate levels of practice testing and increased student test anxiety. Shutterstock

Since the introduction of NAPLAN, there has been a marked increase in the stakes attached to these tests. School results have been made available for public comparison on the My School website. Some schools even use NAPLAN in their marketing and student selection processes.

Other schools and school systems use NAPLAN to hold teachers and school leaders accountable for improvement, including making test results part of performance reviews. And there have been proposals to make NAPLAN results the basis of teacher performance pay and financial rewards for school improvement.

As a result, parents, teachers and schools now place greater importance on NAPLAN results in comparison to the earlier state-based tests. This has led to reports of inappropriate levels of practice testing and increased student test anxiety. It has also narrowed teaching to the test, and led to occasional cheating.

The decision to make all schools’ NAPLAN results public was based on a belief this would provide parents with better information when choosing schools.

This was a market-driven belief that, for schools, the risk of losing students would be a powerful incentive to improve. But test-based incentives have proven largely ineffective in driving school improvement.

We need to reform NAPLAN to make it more useful The current paper test is given to students in years three, five, seven and nine. Shutterstock

Parents have sometimes drawn incorrect conclusions about the quality of a school from publicly reported test results. And public comparisons of schools have resulted in a range of unanticipated negative consequences such as narrowing teaching and increasing levels of teacher and student stress.

An obvious strategy is to stop reporting school results publicly and to restrict access to school-level NAPLAN data to individual schools and school systems. The primary focus of literacy and numeracy testing might then return to its original purpose of informing teaching and learning.

Read more: NAPLAN only tells part of the story of student achievement

Enhance the instructional value of NAPLAN

NAPLAN is a paper test given to students in years three, five, seven and nine, although this year some schools will administer the test online for the first time. The instructional value of these tests appears to be limited in several ways.

  1. Because common year-level tests are too difficult for some students in each year level and too easy for others, NAPLAN provides little information to guide the teaching of these students.

  2. Because the marking of paper tests is a time consuming process, results are provided many weeks after testing, limiting their usefulness to teaching.

  3. NAPLAN tests include only a few items on each literacy and numeracy skill and so are of limited diagnostic value for individual students.

We need to reform NAPLAN to make it more useful An online version of NAPLAN could provide opportunities to improve the quality of the test. Shutterstock

The delivery of NAPLAN online, being gradually implemented from this year, offers an opportunity to address these limitations.

The first step is to continue to get rid of fixed, year-level tests and fully replace them with online “adaptive” tests. In adaptive testing, students are given test questions that are directly targeted to individual students’ skill levels. Adaptive testing provides more precise information about the points individuals have reached in their learning, regardless of their year level.

The benefits of adaptive testing are best realised when the purpose of testing is to establish and understand where individuals are in their skill development. This requires the substantive interpretation of test results by reference to a well-constructed map of long-term skill development.

Read more: NAPLAN online: will Australian schools and students be ready?

NAPLAN scores are expressed on a numerical scale that extends across years three, five, seven and nine. These scores are interpreted with reference to a hierarchy of skill “bands” (or proficiency levels).

The instructional usefulness of NAPLAN will be enhanced by working to describe and illustrate these skill levels in ways that maximise guidance to teaching and learning and by making them the direct reference for understanding students’ NAPLAN performances.

Online delivery and scoring will provide more immediate feedback to teachers and students thus improving NAPLAN’s instructional value.

Delivery in an online environment also introduces the possibility of changing NAPLAN itself. For example, the wrong answers a student gives in numeracy could be used to draw automatic conclusions about the mistakes they are making. This could be checked by giving more questions of the same type and feeding the results back to the teacher.

Authors: Geoff Masters, CEO, Australian Council for Educational Research

Read more http://theconversation.com/we-need-to-reform-naplan-to-make-it-more-useful-93555

Politics

Independent Candidate for the Seat of Gippsland East, Matt Stephenson

MATT STEPHENSON TO GO INTO THE RING WITH BULL A sixth generation East Gippslander is “throwing his hat in the ring” to challenge Tim Bull at the forthcoming state elections. As an aspiring Independen...

Malcolm Turnbull press conference with the Minister for the Environment and Energy

Well the Party Room today has today overwhelmingly supported the National Energy Guarantee, and as a consequence, we are one step closer to cheaper and more reliable energy. This policy is part of ...

Independent Parliamentary Budget Office exposes Shorten's lies

Bill Shorten's false claims about so-called insecure work lie in tatters today, following an analysis published by the independent Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO).  The PBO’s independent analysis...

Business News

3 Tips for Better Management

Running your own team, whether it’s the whole business or simply one department, means making sure that you are a good manager. Being a manager is a lot harder than many people assume, and often mea...

Research reveals the avoidable task 92% of people and businesses are wasting time on

New research commissioned by Zoom2u, an innovative platform that provides radically fast and reliable deliveries, reveals that despite massive tech advancements in the delivery space, 92% of Austral...

JB Hi-Fi battles on despite Amazon

Expected to be one of the most vulnerable companies amid Amazon Australia’s arrival, an emboldened JB Hi-Fi has posted an increase in revenue of 21.8% over 2017-18, to total $6,854.3 million. The gr...

Travel

AYANA Komodo Resort, Waecicu Beach

  20 August Sydney, Australia – 15 September 2018 marks the launch of the first and only 5-star resort on the island of Flores, AYANA Komodo Resort, Waecicu Beach by AYANA Hotels. Alongside the spe...

Discovering South Australia

Hey there! Have you ever thought about visiting Australia? Just imagine road tripping in a Winnebago with your family in tow and enjoying the beauty of the Down Under. If you have never enjoyed visi...

Lake Macquarie for an adventure to match every budget

Explore the environs of Australia’s largest saltwater lake on a shoestring and still have a blast If your tastes for travel out weight your wallet, and low cost or no cost activities are what you ...

You might also like